Soundmasking vs Soundscaping


We have been asked about soundscapes quite a lot recently, so I thought it would be useful explain when they should be considered. “The soundscape is the component of the acoustic environment that can be perceived by humans” (Wikipedia) In our terms consisting of sounds from nature such as running water, wind blowing and/or animal sounds. Although it’s a standard, built-in feature of our system, it should be used with caution.

Sound masking, a technology which has evolved from the first white noise systems in the 1950’s to the very accurate, multi-zonal, adaptive systems we use today have one thing in common - they are designed not to be consciously ‘heard’ by the user. The unobtrusive, non-distracting nature of sound masking is deliberately similar to air conditioning so the occupant of the space is not aware of it.

Soundscaping is useful in certain circumstances. In audibly isolated spaces such as cafe or breakout and relaxation areas additional sounds can add character. If you imagine having a coffee in the office cafe area, it’s obviously a cafe within the office but having used all the practical and visual cues - a real espresso machine and cafe furniture all that’s needed to complete the atmosphere of that place is the sound. With the addition of background cafe sound perhaps a real cafe or just music you can imagine the enhancement to the overall concept. In relaxation zones, the design may suggest how you might use the space but overlaying natural sound will only enhance it for your daily meditation.

The problems occur when you use these sounds throughout the open-plan or cellular office/meeting space. Sound masking increases productivity in open-plan by increasing the ambient sound level (in line with AS2107) to decrease speech intelligibility. The less detail of other conversations you hear, the longer you can stay focused and productive. Sound masking provides this benefit without the user being aware of it. If the sound used is that of a river running or wind blowing no matter how sophisticated its construction, it eventually becomes irritating to at least some of the occupants leading to negative feelings which spread quickly throughout the organisation. This is the fundamental no-go for ambient sound management and very high risk strategy for any customer attempting to create a healthy and productive workplace.

In cellular space, low level sound masking is used to increase confidentiality by improving the effectiveness of the ceiling and partition walls (often enabling the use of floor to ceiling partitioning only, rather than more expensive slab to slab building - see our post about ANU in Canberra where significant savings where made on the fit-out) Sounds from nature are clearly irrelevant here.

In summary, sound masking is a necessary part of a working environment to decrease distraction between workers and increase confidentiality of conversation in cellular space. Soundscaping is a useful addition to this for non-work locations and should not be considered for the entire workplace.

The Silent [Productivity] Killer

The demands on corporate workspace have undergone a revolution in the last decade and building and fit-out design has changed to adapt very well on the whole. However, a new  silent killer has emerged and it's killing productivity without anyone knowing it.

Buildings are are being built better and are quieter or to be more specific, ambient or background sound levels in the resulting office space are becoming much lower.

When ambient sound is low, intelligibility of speech is high and conversations are heard more easily. If you mix that with an activity based working (ABW), flexible working culture which encourages collaboration anywhere at anytime, productivity of those in individual focus takes a nose dive as they are constantly interrupted. Higher ambient sound levels reduce the intelligibility of speech and although adjacent workers normally hear local, relevant team-chat, conversations further away are not intelligible and do not distract.

The simple answer to the problem is to introduce ambient sound artificially using sound masking. Using this technology, in particular the latest evolution Sound Conditioning, ambient sound levels automatically adjust to optimise speech privacy by accurately delivering sound to mask specific speech frequencies. This sound self-adjusts depending on the level of activity in the space. To you and I, it's just like the sound of airconditioning!

Sound Conditioning is now the norm for innovative workspace in Australia. Buildings such as the Barangaroo International Towers, Suncorp's new Shelley Street premises, CBA's Darling Square, Westpac's 275 Kent Street and the latest CLT Accenture building on Hickson Road in Sydney have all embraced this new technology.

Have a look at 45dB Systems new video (below) which explains some of the discomfort quiet workspace creates and how this can be resolved and contact us for more information here.

Sound conditioning saves time and money for ANU

ANU Building 145.jpg

Using sound conditioning not only manages speech privacy which decreases distraction between workers in open-plan it also allows acoustic consultants to re-imagine standard fit-out methods for cellular space.

If there is no control over ambient sound in given workspace, modelling and educated guesswork have to be relied upon to determine what level of ambient sound will be provided by external sources (traffic etc) and construction sources (plant, air conditioning etc). In light of the unpredictability of these elements, in order to guarantee a partition wall will provide adequate privacy it must be built to 'catch all' of those possibilities and must be built slab to slab to a high standard.

Our sound conditioning systems 'lock-in' ambient sound to any spectrum (to mask speech frequencies) and to a decibel level required by the Australian Standard AS2107.

By doing this, progressive acoustic consultants WSP, were able to specify the partitioning on this project for ANU from the floor to the suspended ceiling only negating the need to build above the suspended ceiling into the plenum. This was not only a significant saving on the build cost but also a made for a much more streamlined fit-out.

As ambient sound increases, the partition rating is decreased

As ambient sound increases, the partition rating is decreased

45dB Systems can solve your acoustic issues and make saving on your project.

ANU atrium.jpg

Call us for more information 1300 494 791